90 Comments
User's avatar
Adriana IGV's avatar

The best analysis I’ve read to this moment.

Anthony Dunn's avatar

Superb cogent insights and analysis, Kevork. Thanks.

Daniel O'Connor's avatar

This analysis is beautifully written, but it seems to me that you rather miss a central point.

The present religious leadership of Israel and the Jewish diaspora is completely committed to the strategy of fulfilling key prophecies in sacred texts so as to satisfy the preconditions necessary for God to send the Messiah and bring about the redemption of the Jewish people.

Consequently, Jews believe that they absolutely must (1) conquer the land between the Nile and the Euphrates and (2) build the third Holy Temple on the Temple Mount in Jerusalem.

Nevertheless, a small minority of observant Jews has always opposed this strategy for achieving redemption, believing that it is not in accordance with God's will because it is based on a faulty interpretation of sacred texts.

If Iran can block Israel from fulfilling the key messianic prophecies, this minority will forcefully argue that the impasse proves that their position is right. The longer the impasse continues, the more convincing their view will become, and eventually it will be adopted by the worldwide Jewish community.

It follows that Iran must seize the present opportunity to secure an overland corridor across Iraq and Syria so that it can again supply and reinforce Hezbollah in Lebanon and Iran's Alawite allies along the Mediterranean coast in Syria.

Shia military forces must then roll back all territorial gains recently made by the Israelis in southern Syria.

The Shias also need to take back the Golan Heights from Israel and penetrate into Israel and gain a defensible position in the West Bank.

It would be highly desirable for the Palestinian majority in Jordan to take power there and to establish a military force along the border with Israel, especially near Jerusalem.

Means must also be found to get adequate supplies to the civilian population in Gaza.

Some such initiative as this would greatly help to bring about peace with the minimum loss of life on all sides.

Thank you, Kevork, for all you are doing, and for the inspiring example you provide.

Naomi / Reflections in Time's avatar

And here in America we have a ruling party of nationalists that have a similar belief, rooted in a fundamentalist misunderstanding of Revelation that allies with Israel hand in glove. I’ve included this in my recent Substack article. Wake up America project 2025 is rolling into 26.

Daniel O'Connor's avatar

Yes, so-called "Christian" Zionism, along with British Israelism, Hindutvu in India, and similar ideologies have been successfully infiltrated into religious faiths throughout the world.

Each has been ingeniously designed to provide crucial support for the achievement of the goals of Zionism in Israel.

All of these related religious belief systems are (1) messianic, (2) fundamentalist (rely on a literal interpretation of sacred texts), and (3) zealous (pursued with a fanatical fervor that readily embraces the use of violence).

Israeli historian Gershom Scholem insisted that Zionism was so dangerous it threatened the continued existence of the Jewish people.

His warning was ignored, and true believers in Israel are probably welcoming the missile attacks on their nation today as the "birth pangs" proving that the arrival of the Messiah is imminent.

Naomi / Reflections in Time's avatar

Those of us still sentient of mind and body know that a new axial age is gestating. But the labor appears to be infinitely long and hideously painful. We may need forceps and a strong crew to clean up afterwards, whenever that might be…could be down the road…could be millennia. Maybe this sounds trite, maybe it is, but that is where I am at the moment. Carry on, Dan.

StraightTalk's avatar

You don't know about Hindu and Hindutva. Hindutva literally means being a Hindu

हिंदुत्व

अहिंसा परमो धर्मः

धर्म हिंसा तथैव च

Non-violence is the ultimate dharma.

So too is violence in service of Dharma.

Dharma/ Dharm means Duty

For us Duty is Religion unlike for you religion is a performative duty

A Hindu is supremely tolerant till pushed to the wall - by peaceful religion (Muslim)/ only true path (Christian) adherents aided and abetted by God's chosen people (Jew) and the Marxists

Daniel O'Connor's avatar

Hindutva has been described by some scholars as a form of "Hindu nationalism" with fundamentalist and xenophobic tendencies.

India's current ruling political party, the BJP, officially adopted Hindutva as its ideology in a 1989 resolution.

After BJP leader Narendra Modi was elected prime minister in 2014, India formed a strategic partnership with Israel in 2017.

During an official visit to Israel less than a month ago, Prime Minister Modi emphasized that "India stands with Israel."

I think it would be fair to say that Hindutva has been a major factor behind the support given to Zionism by the current Indian government.

Until he was murdered by so-called "Hindu nationalists" in 1948, Mohandas Gandhi, the leader of the nonviolent movement for Indian independence from the British Empire, steadfastly refused to endorse Zionism.

Gandhi's outstanding leadership was rooted in Hinduism and its sacred texts, which are among the greatest works of religious thought and literary artistry in the world.

This magnificent tradition is what makes India great, not Hindutva.

Harry Storm's avatar

He doesn't know about lots of stuff, including the so-called "messiahism" of orthodox jewry.

Harry Storm's avatar

That is even more delusional, verging on insane. You obviously are clueless about many things, but especially about the Jewish diaspora, which could care less about the messiahand isn't even particularly religious. for the most part. Idiotica.

Daniel O'Connor's avatar

Mr. Shore assures us that the Jewish diaspora is not messianic, but Jewish historian Gershom Scholem concluded that messianism is the very essence of Judaism.

Mr. Shore also insists that the Jewish diaspora isn’t religious but immediately qualifies this assertion by adding “for the most part.” However, this is the same diaspora of whom Israel Shahak said, “Israel is their God.”

Zionism is a messianic ideology profoundly influenced by Judaism and it is widely embraced by diaspora Jews; so, they are rather more religious than not.

Further, if the Jewish diaspora were not religious, then one might expect their reaction to criticism of Judaism, Israel, or Zionism to be one of indifference or mild disagreement.

In his three-sentence-long comment, Mr. Shore relies on such terms as “delusional,” “insane,” “clueless,” and “idiotic.” His vitriolic style of argumentation undercuts the very points he is attempting to establish.

Harry Storm's avatar

Yeah yeah yeah. It's true, 90-95% of Jews support Israel in its existential struggle, i.e. struggle to maintain its existence against all the forces arrayed against it. But there support is mostly secular, not religious, just as the founders of Israel did so as secularists. Further, this tinkers-to-evers-to-chance assertion -- Gershom Sholom says judaism is messianism, and Israel Shahak says "Israel is their God, misses a few significant things. One, 90% of diaspora Jews aren't religious, and therefore, whether judaism is messianic or not is irrelevant. Shahak can say whatever he wants, but secular Jewish support for Israel is no different than ex-pat Italian support for Italy would be if that country were under constant existential threat. Is Italy "their god." Or that of diaspora Iranians, who seem quite ecstatic that the regime that oppresses their countrymen so brutally may be about to fall. Is Iran "their god:"? It's a silly assertion. And no, one ought not to expect "criticism" -- which appears to include demonization, delegitimization and double-standards -- of Israel to be one of indifference or mild disagreement when the country in question is under constant threat, but that is the reaction of most secular jews when Judaism is criticized. Problem is, most Israel-haters and jew-haters (often one and the same) hardly ever criticize "judaism" when they go after Jews or Israel. Religious affiliation didn't matter to the nazis, and it doesn't feature very significantly among Israel critics either. As for my "vitriolic style of argumentation," get stuffed. When you can't engage the substance, you focus on the so-called vitriol, most of which is actually descriptive and well-earned.

Harry Storm's avatar

RE: The present religious leadership of Israel and the Jewish diaspora is completely committed to the strategy of fulfilling key prophecies in sacred texts so as to satisfy the preconditions necessary for God to send the Messiah and bring about the redemption of the Jewish people. Consequently, Jews believe that they absolutely must (1) conquer the land between the Nile and the Euphrates and (2) build the third Holy Temple on the Temple Mount in Jerusalem.

Clearly you are a total nutter. And of course, being a supporter of Iran and Islamism generally, it's a huge case of projection. It's the shia of Iran whose eschatology requires massive destruction to bring back the mahdi. You're projecting that onto the Jews. Not one in 500 Jews, religious or secular, remotely think like this. And of course, the whole Greater Israel Nile-to-Euphrates business is just horseshit from start to finish. As if Israel needs to absorb tens of millions more Arab Muslims. The only lands Israel is remotely interested in are Judea and Samaria (the West Bank), the Golan Heights (for obvious security reasons), and of late, parts of southern Lebanon (because of Hezbollah bombardments). You may recall that Israel returned Sinai to Egypt in 1979, evacuated south Lebanon in 2000, and disengaged from Gaza in 2005. Some big expansionists. Nobody except nutters want anything more, and many don't even want judea and samaria, if the Palestinians there can come to their senses and actually sincerely negotiate a two-state solution. Aside from a few fringe of the fringe of the fringe, nobody else wants anything more. They're nutters, you actually have much in common with them.

Laurie Z's avatar

On the psychological front, there is also the unraveling of narrative as we in the west are being forced to confront the ‘other’.

There is what we’ve been told; that ‘they’ are barbaric, uncivilized terrorists and there is the reality of who they have shown themselves to be through the highly intelligent, sophisticated and rational response that we are all witnessing.

The real barbarians bombed a school and then lied about it.

Wolfgang Exel Watson's avatar

There is a side effect that is not fully explored, or investigated. Trump supporters - the people that helped him to arrive at his present position - have not only been lied to. They have been lied to with most detrimental consequences to their existence. Although the same can be said about Europe, but there at least are dissenting nations.

Especially the hard core Trump enablers will now feel the devastating impact of the hubris they supported, gave power to obey to a small group of super humans that has taken over total control over their homeland. The Iran war is waking up Americans who could not be bothered to stand up in masses to protest the eradication of Gaza. Now, that the lies have become blatantly obvious and existentially threatening, the premeditated murder of young girls and boys creates repulsion on top of the economic assault.

Here in Florida, where most Trump supporters are using the worst gas guzzler the market had to offer, gas prices went up over ten percent in four days. Diesel is now above $ 5.00. Diesel is the fuel needed by the transportation industry. Everything is carted around by diesel engines - even the train locomotives run with diesel. The increase that is here to stay, will wreak havoc on those who have been so far unaffected by the hubristic policies of the Epstein class. This is no longer guaranteed. The remainder of the so called middle class is sliding into the lower Kast now. Auctions are reflecting the sell offs of the Trump supporters' toys. Boats, ATV's, motor cycles, jet skies, surplus cars need to go. Saturating a market that is already dead - if not for the rich that go on shopping sprees now for previously unavailable items.

The western populations have in a trance like fashion allowed the hubristic leadership to sail the ship into the iceberg. It is sinking. Are there any solutions? Of course. Are they implementable? Probably not. The masses would have to drop their apathy and empty the houses of representation - as they are not represented any longer. Foreign influence must be removed from politics. Corruption must be punished in the harshest way possible.

Those, who are responsible for crimes against humanity and war crimes must be banned from holding any public offices ever again - on top of their prosecution for these crimes.

LJones's avatar

Trump is just the carnival barker. The ruling class belched up all this nonsense and they ALL supported it, and that includes the NYT's. Do you seriously think Kamala Harris would've prevented it? The national security state is the perp....

Wolfgang Exel Watson's avatar

Of course not. Which makes it even more tragic. However, the population must be united - to not fall. In order to get there, both "teams" need to overcome their delusions about their teams being superior/special/etc. The only mindset that can save US is "we are all in this together and public enemy Nº1 are the billionaire class. The epstein clients and their tools.

Paul Schatzkin's avatar

I keep looking for a hook to hang some optimism or hope on, but then read a sanguine assessment of the reality like this one and have to conclude that hope and optimism are a fools game, now.

Chevrus's avatar

Think of it this way: the factors that are intersecting to create this massive cataclysmic shift have been a long time in the making. Some of them are in human control others are more overarching and based on structural mechanics. Yes there are going to be some rough seas ahead and depending on where a band who you are, it could get pretty severe. The upside however is that it all paves the way to a much more reasonable way to do commerce and build trade relations. Why do I say that? Because it could not be much worse and still function, for the majority of the world population.

Paul Schatzkin's avatar

So…You’re saying… it will be better… after it gets much worse? That’s probably what some Germans thought in 1940. i feel so much better now!

Naomi / Reflections in Time's avatar

Or, it may shift. The power of empire may be reaching a climax. A new world order is overdue. What comes next is unknown. We humans have to get over our sense of entitlement and learn respect for all of life on and within this planet.

Paul Schatzkin's avatar

Naomi, I can only hope (there I go again..) that what you're describing is within the realm of possibility. But at this point the skeptic and cynic "is strong in this one," and I keep coming back to that line in Jackson Browne's "Before The Deluge" where he writes of "the magnitude of the fury in the final hour." And we're not there yet, on either side.

Chevrus's avatar

You are WELCOME!

Sal's avatar

And this is exactly why USrael must be planning a false flag to gain the support for a horrifying nuclear attack. Please write about this possibility and the existing signals pointing to it.

Sez77's avatar

Trump and Co couldn't have missed the outpouring of support by everyday Iranians, many of whom were not supportive of their Government, but who turned out in droves nonetheless when the U.S assassinated their leader.

There's been a recent background drum-beating narrative of “plots to assassinate Trump”.

Headlines like: “Iran's head of National Security Ali Latijani warns Trump ‘Be careful not to get yourself eliminated’.

Another: “Pakistani man Asif Merchant on trial in Brooklyn for Trump assassination plot says he was recruited by Iran”.

And yet another: “Waukesha man Nikita Casap gets life in prison for parents’ murder to fund plot to kill Trump”.

1. When it's clear this misguided U.S initiative has failed spectacularly and gouged out a massive hole in Trump's base...

2. When we witnessed the miraculous effects of the Charlie Kirk “assassination” at herding the sheep back into the fold...

3. When its demonstrated that massive support can be mobilised for an assassinated Iranian leader even if he wasn't universally popular with his people...

- the possibilities of a fake Trump “assassination” surely can't be completely off the table.

Vee's avatar

What makes you think that this is a miscalculation when the governments of the world are pawns on a chess board that are controlled by a psychopathic ruling class that is hellbent on enslaving humanity?

Alan Allen's avatar

Iran got suckered y the U.S./ Israel club too many times already and has had enough. Hormuz hardball woke them up and changes the whole program. The world is watching and learning.

Geoffrey Robertson's avatar

Interesting perspectives, but what if, from a technocratic perspective, the response from Iran to close Homuz was a calculated strategy all along. I mean, can you think of a better way to collapse supply chains, industries, governments, and societies around the world in order to provide the opening they need to install their global technocracy?

Richard Biggar's avatar

Never underestimate the depth of Satan’s evil.

JCRodrig's avatar

Excellent analysis of the true cost of a blunder by USA/Israel.

Sanjay Mehta's avatar

Arrogance + Stupidity = Hubris

Rose C.'s avatar

Very interesting analysis. This miscalculation is why I wanted us to leave the USS Ford in the Caribbean.

One major point I will disagree on: Beijing. They are a far greater national security threat to the United States (and to the world, really). COVID taught us that. I want no part of the dystopian modification of the human genome the CCP is currently working on in combination with AI, and neither should the rest of humanity. It will make all of the fighting over oil look pleasant.

Nescio's avatar

With all due respect, I get the impression from your comment - moreover: I am deeply concerned - that you are afflicted by serious chinophrenia. This is a condition widely affecting the entire West.

I do not deny that there is "the dystopian modification of the human genome ... in combination with AI" going on as we comment here on Kevork's analysis. Yet it is not the CCP, but the very US-home-grown sociopath technofeudalist cabal around Peter Thiel, Alex Karp, Elon Musk and their fascist ilk that pursue what you accuse China of: the complete domination of the planet by means of erasing every and all "life not worthy to live" (In Epstein Syndicate parlance: "How do we get rid of the poor?") - in no way different, but indeed exactly the same as "lebensunwertes Leben" in Nazi-German.

Kevork is correct: we witness the 21st century redo of the 19th century Great Game. the earlier one pursued by Perfidious Albion, the present one by the bastard empire it spawned, the US, and that other bastard created by the English as " ‘a little loyal Jewish Ulster’ in a sea of potentially hostile Arabism”, as Ronald Storrs, a British governor of Jerusalem between 1917 and 1926 put it in his book 'Orientations' [ watch David Cronin's expose at https://youtu.be/y8OIxEGI1zQ; and read his book 'Balfour's Shadow: A Century of British Support for Zionism and Israel' (Paperback – July 15, 2017) ]

This brings me back to the cause of what I cannot otherwise describe as chinophrenia: the ancient venerable civilization known as China, its people(s) and its leadership. China has been exactly where Iran - it, too, is, like China, an ancient and venerable civilization - has been since 1953: it suffered its "century of humiliation" as the result of Perfidious Albion's waging two Opium Wars (1839-42; 1856-60). The result is the history that followed, right up to today.

Now China is making sure that Iran, and with Iran, it and Russia and the entire Global Majority (I leave India out for the moment, for very recent obvious reasons which you can find out easily) succeeds in ending once and for all the humiliation imposed by the West as "rules based international order".

Deterrence restored or nothing, indeed.

This is presently, very precisely (in every sense of the word) being executed by the Islamic Republic of Iran, or, more accurately, by the Civilization State of Iran, through the means Kevork describes here in his essay. The US' - it being the consummate antithesis of civilization state - catch phrase lie fed to the gullible American and European publics and other gullibles (soon to be distracted by FIFA's "panem et circenses", "bread and games" by means of the Soccer World Cup) goes like this: "Short term pain, long term gain".

It is, as everyone outside the West has no difficulty to see, the other way around, namely Iran's, China's, Russia's and the way of all other civilized nations on planet Earth: "Short term gain (Trump's hollow declarations of 'victory'), very long term pain" - initially not so much for the US as it has its own energy resources, but not for long, and, already, certainly for its vassal colonies in Europe, including the UK. They shall live. But they must be neutered (Europe already is). The non-western world will suffer, too: inspired by the Great Suffering of Iran, this non-western world understands deeply that its call is to give witness as "with-ness" to this Great Suffering. It is long acquainted, intimately familiar with it.

The West imposed suffering. Now it is destined to have it imposed on it. Unfettered Deterrence no more. Nothing in its stead. In spades. By its own making.

That leaves, in my view, still the urgent task of taking on and - forever!!! - out the International Finance Epstein Syndicate, the financiers who make the stratospheric profits off this and all other wars going on at the moment (The City of London and Wall Street, in that order).

Which is why Hormuz is so vitally important for the civilized, i.e. non-western world.

Which, in turn, is why China is now even more active in the creation of a non-US-Dollar financial system, with the objective of replacing the petrodollar with the petroyuan. Not to merely rule by coercion, but to liberate humanity and embark on the future which is characterized by mutual respect and equity, and in which conflict resolution happens through dialogue and compromise.

(Isn't the pervasive russo- and chinophrenia which keeps infecting so many people in the West to the level of incurability not in fact just another among the many manifestations, or one of the "Ur-Manifestationen", " 'primeordeal' manifestations" of the Undead Western Imperial Colonial Mindset, or - pardon the expression - mindfuck?)

As for Iran, specifically Hormuz: I prefer the official Iranian position. It is as simple as it is brilliant and profound: "The Strait of Hormuz isn't closed. Not at all. It just isn't open."

By the way: Rather than China, Pfizer may have to answer many more disturbing questions about COVID and its COVID-vaccine. This, however, is a pharmatologicopolitical issue which I am not qualified enough to discuss, and for which this forum is not the place. (Ask Ursula von der Leyen. She knows. But, she has " unfortunately deleted her SMS messages from her phone". To those who believe it: bless your heart.)

To you, my fellow commentators here, and to Kevork: my apology for for writing this very long response. I respectfully and humbly request your forgiveness. It is, after all, easier to obtain than permission... ;-)

Libertarian's avatar

Brilliant analysis; relevant, clear, complete, organized, compelling and insightful. It will likely get you on lists that most prefer not to be on. The simplistic and extreme bias I see on pro-Zionist Substacks and their comments make wonder if Scotty didn’t somehow beam me to Tel Aviv in my sleep. I read thousands of comments from people who were never in the military but are nonetheless devoted to sending off to war young Americans too poor to get into college. Thank-you.

Matrix2008's avatar

Spot on Edgar. The Irony in that our population here in the US are so far removed from the understanding of what is planned for them which is enslavement then methodical extinction spearheaded by our maniacal, mind-controlled President. Ai transhumanist-Mass surveillance-digital id all Gov sanctioned private public investment with Palantir, Oracle, Blackrock, Miltary, CIA-FBi-Mo€€ad-DHS-ICE exc. All of them ultimately controlled by bankers and all will play key roles in destroying our populations. Clamity full speed ahead

ordinarypeople's avatar

Forgiveness not necessary! Thank you for spreading truth and enlightenment.

Rose C.'s avatar

Counterpoint to your argument that I am suffering from some kind of “affliction:” I like the Cuban people very much. I dislike the Cuban intelligence services (the Dirección de Inteligencia) running the Cuban Communist party. Similarly, Beijing's intelligence services (their spies) are quite aggressive, and an adversary of the United States.

Nescio's avatar

I like the Cuban, Chinese, Iranian, Russian, and, yes, the American people very much. Even non-zionist Israeli people, the true daughters and sons of Israel. I dislike Mossad and CIA and MI6 far more than the intelligence services you despise. BTW: intelligence services are part of the game. I like to remind you that Harry Truman in the later years of his life regretted having approved the establishment of the CIA in 1947. And, of course, President Eisenhower's prescient warning for the American Military Industrial Complex.

At least we see eye to eye in dislike of intelligence services, don't we?

Rose C.'s avatar

Actually, I love a good master of counterintelligence. We haven't been very good at counterintelligence historically in the United States, thanks to our set-up under the FBI, but as the Zen Master says...we'll see.

Phil Smith's avatar

Why doesn't if occur to you that the U.S. did the modifying? It was their lab. They were paying for everything. If the Chinese wanted a pandemic, why wouldn't they have launched it from one of their labs in the states? Oh yeah. They didn't have any.

Rose C.'s avatar

Well, Phil, this is precisely why people don't like Anthony Fauci and the GOF research done with Beijing's intelligence services, who always weasel their way like snakes into our R1 Universities. Fauci, the same man who said he was "excited" about the emergence of the AIDS virus back in the 80s.

We need a domestic intelligence service like our friends at ASIO.

doug elford's avatar

An excellent analysis that explains again that Iran has only one option to survive and not become another Libya, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon or worse Jordan .

Michel Rocheleau's avatar

History has a way for twisted outcomes. The Palestinians stone in the giant brutal arrogant western empire shoe will make them fall

Lindsey Louther's avatar

Simple. Clear. Unambiguous. Thank you Kevork for an excellent analysis.

Simple logic: we want your oil and we will take it same as Venezuela. No excuses, feigning of concern, ideological nonsense.

Don’t expect us to love you when you murder our children and abuse us in the worst manner possible.

We, a 5 000 year old CIVILISATION, don’t want the Americanisation of our society.